This large competitor of Burrows, Lightbourn has also been selling liquor on Bermuda since 1806. You can buy Gosling's Black Seal dark rum -- perhaps one bottle to sample on the island and another as an "in-bond" purchase to take home. "In-bond" items cannot be consumed on the island; they can only be exported. The bottle you drink on the island is likely to cost 50% more than the "in-bond" bottle. If you want to buy liquor to take home under your duty-free allowance, you can arrange to have it sent to the airport. There's another location, the Black Seal Shop (under the same ownership despite having a different name), at 17 Dundonald St.